PRACTICAL KNOWLEDGE
What is a logic analyzer?
A logic analyzer is an electronic measuring device that can characterize and graphically display digital signals over time.
Read article
Advantages of using an I2C protocol analyzer over an oscilloscope
Analysis of I2C & SPI Protocol
The ability to analyze accurately via I2C and SPI is of paramount importance for debugging at the system and hardware level. Embedded systems engineers have found two common solutions and techniques when working with these popular serial buses:
1. Oscilloscopes
2. Protocol analyzers
Each solution can be extremely effective depending on the use case. Understanding the key differences is critical to choosing the optimal approach.
What is the difference between a protocol analyzer and an oscilloscope?
Basically the main differences are:
Oscilloscope
- Provides physical waveform
- Snapshot of the waveform
- Protocol decoding options
Protocol Analyzer
- Provides log data (hex)
- Large buffer of data streams
- No waveform, just a log
Basically, each method offers different options for analyzing embedded systems. Oscilloscopes are very useful for troubleshooting electrical problems, but the data they collect is at a very low level. However, a key function is that they perform a quick diagnosis using visual data that represents elements such as jitter, noise, and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR).
Unlike oscilloscopes, protocol analyzers allow engineers to effectively debug at a higher level. Protocol analyzers allow users to view the data in decoded form, easily understandable packets, rather than just individual bit streams. They also allow engineers to stream low-level data packets and bus events for further debugging.
What are the advantages of using a protocol analyzer over an oscilloscope?
Portable
Protocol analyzers are typically hand-held and extremely useful in any laboratory or even in a home test environment, unlike larger oscilloscopes which, due to their size, may not be ideal for certain applications.
Plug and Play
Not only do protocol analyzers take up less space than oscilloscopes, but they are easy to set up because of their plug-and-play configuration with a host PC and their ability to work in multiple operating system environments.
Real-time data and detailed analysis
Protocol analyzers with real-time data acquisition capabilities allow engineers to quickly monitor and view packet-level data in real time over the I2C or SPI bus, making it easier to locate valuable data transfers and potential errors, resulting in more thorough analysis and troubleshooting. Relevant data points that can often be examined with protocol analyzers include:
- Transaction timestamp
- Transaction duration
- error message
- Start or stop command
- Device address
- Decoded data
Cost differences
Typical oscilloscopes can be expensive, running in the low to high five digits, while most protocol analyzers remain at a fraction of the cost.
In conclusion, using an oscilloscope or a protocol analyzer has its main advantages depending on the level of use. However, protocol analyzers have become a method of choice for the embedded system engineer.
How does the Beagle I2C / SPI protocol analyzer compare to other analyzers?
Choosing the right solution is an important process. Tools like Total Phase's industry-leading Beagle I2C / SPI protocol analyzer are designed to enable engineers to debug and develop embedded applications using serial buses more easily, faster, and more cheaply.
In particular, the Beagle I2C / SPI Protocol Analyzer is a portable device that enables engineers to quickly and easily analyze and debug I2C and SPI traffic in real time. This function is specific to total phase analyzers. While many protocol analyzers operate in different operating system environments, Total Phase's Beagle I2C / SPI protocol analyzer offers cross-platform support and can run in the most common environments such as Windows, Mac OS and Linux. Our analyzers provide insight into various data transactions and offer the option of filtering data as required. In addition, our Beagle I2C / SPI protocol analyzer is one of the most cost-effective protocol sniffing solutions in the embedded field, making it an ideal tool for many engineers.
For more information on how this device can aid your debugging efforts, please visit the Beagle I2C / SPI Protocol Analyzer product page.
